Does the Church Know God’s Heart is Broken?

I hope you love the products and resources I recommend here at A Little R & R. Just so you know, it is possible that I get a commission and collect income from the links on this page. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Click here for more info.

There is no betrayal quite like the betrayal of a spouse.

When the person you’ve trusted most betrays that trust, the pain cuts deeply.

But perhaps one of the most painful parts of betrayal is when the person who hurt you doesn’t even realize they’ve done it.

They carry on as though everything is normal.

They talk to you.

They spend time with you.

They may even buy you gifts.

But they don’t recognize that what you really want isn’t another gift.

You want their heart.

This is the picture Hosea gives us of God’s relationship with Israel.

Israel was still performing religious activities. They were still offering sacrifices. They still claimed to know God.

But God was looking at their hearts and saying, in essence:

You are doing religious things, but you don’t know Me.

When Religious Activity Replaces Relationship

“For I desire loyalty and not sacrifice and the knowledge of God more than burnt offerings.” Hosea 6:6

Israel hadn’t stopped being religious.

That’s what makes Hosea so sobering.

They were still bringing sacrifices.

They were still using the language of faith.

They could even say, “My God, we know You!”

But God knew their hearts.

Their religious activity had become a substitute for relationship.

God Isn’t Looking for a Perfect Spiritual Checklist

God isn’t nearly as concerned with whether we’ve checked every religious box as He is with whether we actually know Him.

Dear sister, God isn’t nearly as concerned with

• How many Sundays in a row you attend church
• If you pay your tithe each month without missing
• If you’ve read through the whole Bible every year from cover to cover
• What your reading streak is on YouVersion

He isn’t nearly as concerned that you’ve checked all of the boxes as much as He is concerned with how sincere your relationship is with Him.

None of these things are bad.

In fact, many of them are good things.

But good spiritual practices can become substitutes for actually knowing God.

God Doesn’t Hate Our Spiritual Disciplines

God isn’t asking us to stop going to church.

He isn’t telling us that Bible reading doesn’t matter.

He isn’t saying that giving, serving, praying, or memorizing Scripture is unnecessary.

The problem comes when we use those things to convince ourselves that we’re close to God while our hearts are actually far from Him.

What good is it if we attend church every Sunday without fail, if during the week we entertain ourselves with books and movies that are filled with profanity, violence, and immorality?

Will God overlook the fact that we’re more willing to listen to psychology experts than His Word, just because we are faithful to pay our tithe each month?

Will He overlook our “safe sex” talk with our kids or the fact that we’re living with (or sleeping with) our boyfriend as long as we read through the Bible each year or have a perfect reading streak on YouVersion?

God doesn’t want our checked boxes!

God wants loyalty; He wants to be heard!

Knowing About God Isn’t the Same as Knowing God

God doesn’t want the empty platitudes of “My God, we know you” (8:2) when we raise our hands in worship on Sunday, when we were out drinking and partying with friends on Saturday.

When we truly know God; when he has been “heard” by us; when our heart is no longer divided – one side in the church and the other side in the world…

It won’t be about checked boxes for us; it will be about dwelling in His pleasure.

It won’t be about keeping our 6:00 A.M. quiet time, because we’ll be communicating with Him all throughout the day.

It won’t be about trying to buy His affirmation with tithe and checked boxes, because we will be assured of His love…because we truly do know Him.

Not just intellectually, but intimately.

A Heart Divided Between God and the World

The problem wasn’t that Israel didn’t know how to worship.

The problem was that their hearts were divided.

They wanted God—and they wanted the idols.

They wanted the blessings of belonging to God without surrendering themselves completely to Him.

And a divided heart eventually produces a divided life.

We can do the same thing.

We can sing about surrender on Sunday while protecting the very things God is asking us to surrender on Monday.

We can ask God to bless our lives while refusing to let Him govern them.

We can want God’s comfort without wanting His correction.

God Wants Loyalty, Not Just Sacrifice

God doesn’t want empty religious activity.

He wants loyalty.

He wants our hearts.

He wants to be heard.

He wants us to know Him—not merely intellectually, but intimately.

He wants a relationship with us that changes the way we live.

When we truly know God, obedience stops being merely a checklist.

Prayer stops being merely an appointment on the calendar.

Bible reading stops being something we have to check off.

Worship stops being something we do for an hour on Sunday.

Our relationship with God begins to spill into every part of our day.

Is My Christianity Becoming a Checklist?

1. Am I doing things for God that I’m not actually doing with God?
2. Am I more concerned with appearing spiritually faithful than actually being faithful?
3. Do I allow God’s Word to correct me, or do I only want it to encourage me?
4. Is there an area of my life I’m asking God to bless while refusing to surrender it to Him?
5. Do I know God—or have I simply accumulated knowledge about Him?
6. If all my religious activities disappeared tomorrow, would I still want Jesus?

How Do We Move From Religious Activity to Relationship?

1. Slow down enough to listen.

Don’t turn Bible reading into another box to check.

2. Read Scripture to know God, not merely finish a reading plan.

3. Talk to God throughout the day.

Prayer doesn’t have to be confined to one quiet-time slot.

4. Obey what God shows you.

Relationship produces obedience.

5. Invite God to examine your heart.

Psalm 139:23–24 would fit beautifully here.

6. Let God have the areas you’ve been protecting.

This gives readers something concrete to do.

Dig into God’s Word Today!

• Find all my favorite resources in one place in my Amazon Storefront
  
  A Bible
• A journal or notebook
• Pens
• Bible highlighters
• Colored pens or pencils if you enjoy Bible journaling
• Sticky notes or tabs for marking important passages

God Wants Your Heart

Imagine a wife whose husband gives her beautiful gifts every week but never listens to her.

He buys flowers.

He buys jewelry.

He pays the bills.

He does everything he thinks a good husband should do.

But he never gives her his attention.

He never listens to her heart.

He never wants to spend time with her.

Would those gifts make her feel loved?

Or would she eventually say, “I don’t need another gift. I need you.”

That’s the picture Hosea gives us.

God doesn’t need another religious performance from us.

He wants us.

He wants our loyalty.

He wants our attention.

He wants our surrender.

He wants us to know Him.

Not merely know about Him.

Know Him.

So perhaps the question isn’t simply, “Am I doing enough for God?”

Perhaps the better question is:

“Does God have my heart?”

Because when He has our heart, obedience isn’t about checking boxes.

Prayer isn’t about maintaining a streak.

Bible reading isn’t about finishing a plan.

Worship isn’t confined to Sunday morning.

Our entire lives become an expression of knowing and loving Him.

God doesn’t want your checklist. He wants your heart.